First For Music News

In The NME Office - Behind the scenes at NME -  Behind the scenes at NME

By Luke Lewis

Posted on 06/11/09 at 04:11:33 pm

This week we kicked off our Decade In Music series with a look back at NME critics' 50 best albums of 2000.

If we made a fresh list now, with the gift of hindsight, it'd probably look a lot different. I doubt we'd place Coldplay's 'Parachutes' above Radiohead's 'Kid A', as the mag team did nine years ago. And I can't imagine we'd place Badly Drawn Boy so highly, or go quite so crazy for Kelis.

But hey, maybe in a decade's time people will be equally mystified by the current NME team's love of The Horrors.

Here's the full list of 50. What do you think? Any glaring omissions? Is QOTSA's 'Rated R' a weird choice for Number 1, or does it still stand up as a classic album?

continued...

50. Gorky’s Zygotic Mynci, ‘The Blue Tree’. NME said: “23 minutes of magical, and wildly esoteric beauty that suggested the band had remained indifferent to the rise of nu-metal.”
49. Grand Drive, ‘True Love And High Adventure’. NME said: “Awash with lush psychedelia and opiated melancholy, and a neat sideline in timeless melodicism.”
48. Q-Tip, ‘Amplified’. NME said: “Electric, bubbling beats and pro-peace, love-making and inderstanding rhymes.”
47. Madonna, ‘Music’. NME said: “ ‘Music’ proved there was still a great deal on offer from the mother of reinvention.”
46. Magnetic Fields, ‘69 Love Songs’. NME said: “A victory for art, as well as a set of repeated hits to the soul.”
45. Ryan Adams, ‘Heartbreaker’. NME said: “Folk classicism at its finest.”
44. Amen, ‘We Have Come For Your Parents’. NME said: “A very bloody postcard from the edge.”
43. Clinic, ‘Internal Wrangler’. NME said: “A brief but unforgettable experience.”
42. Outkast, ‘Stankonia’. NME said: “A creative and often humorous undertaking that humanised gangsta rap, strayed into radical territory and confounded expectations at every turn.”
41. David Holmes, ‘Bow Down To The Exit Sign’. NME said: “Hugely enjoyable if slightly pretentious spoken-word designer trip-hop.”
40. Black Box Recorder, ‘The Facts Of Life’. NME said: “A panoramic view of life and love on our nostalgia-choked, emotionally repressed island.”
39. Asian Dub Foundation, ‘Community Music’. NME said: “ADF’s second suite of musical Molotov cocktails hits hard.”
38. Leila, ‘Courtesy Of Choice’. NME said: “A joyous, melancholy, baffling, partly ironic and unnervingly direct set of songs.”
37. Paul Weller, ‘Heliocentric’. NME said: “All class. No act.”
36. Ghostface Killah, ‘Supreme Clientele’. NME said: “Worthwhile for the sheer sense of feeling on its own.”
35. Sigur Ros, ‘Agaetis Byrjun’. NME said: “The sound of baby whales being born under erupting volcanoes. Beautiful and impenetrable.”
34. Marilyn Manson, ‘Holy Wood (In The Valley Of The Shadow Of Death)’. NME said: “A series of heroic rallying cries for the disenfranchised, while also baiting the American Far Right for all its worth.”
33. Shellac, ‘1000 Hurts’. NME said: “The uncomfortable sound of betrayal, and of broken relationships is accompanied by his band’s harshest music yet.”
32. Johnny Cash, ‘American Iii: Solitary Man’. NME said: “This’ll be the only time you’ll see the Man In Black run for cover.”
31. Two Lone Swordsman, ‘Tiny Reminders’. NME said: “Electro in sensibility.”
30. The Kingsbury Manx, ‘The Kingsbury Manx’. NME said: “Grown men gulped openly at its melancholy beauty.”
29. The Dandy Warhols , ‘Thirteen Tales From Urban Bohemia’. NME said: “Stepped in psychedelia, this had its head in the clouds, and its heart broken but beginning to mend.”
28. The Delgados, ‘The Great Eastern’. NME said: “A slow-motion charmer with elegantly beautiful depths.”
27. Smog, ‘Dongs Of Sevotion’. NME said: “Callahan harbours unsuspected tenderness.”
26. Bell And Sebastian, ‘Fold Your Hands Child, You Walk Like A Peasant’. NME said: “B&S at their finest – intricate strings, unimpeachable melodies and enough charm to silence even the staunchest critic.”
25. Jeff Buckley, ‘Mystery White Boy’. NME said: “This is a joyous celebration, underwritten with incoming tragedy.”
24. Six By Seven, ‘The Closer You Get’. NME said: “A wrought work of bitter anger and in places stark terror.”
23. Broadcast, ‘The Noise Made By People’. NME said: “The Birmingham quintet’s pop experiments produced emotional results.”
22. Delta, ‘Slippin’ Out’. NME said: “A determined triumph over adversity, here was proof that – eventually – the good will out.”
21. Wu-Tang Clan, ‘The W’. NME said: “Dark, menacing, smoked-out, rhythmically years ahead and lyrically in a new rap dimension.”
20. Richard Ashcroft, ‘Alone With Everybody’. NME said: “Was ever a man so full of love?”
19. The Go-Betweens, ‘The Friend Of Rachel Worth’. NME said: “A set of ruminations on love and dilapidated German castles that sprang to life with a vigour one might have expected to have diminished.”
18. The For Carnation,’ The For Carnation’. NME said: “The power of strong words, softly spoken.”
17. Elliott Smith, ‘Figure 8’. NME said: “This time, his poison was FM pop splendour, luch Beatles instrumentation merging with his lyrical grace.”
16. Godspeed You Black Emperor!, ‘Levez Vos Skinny Fists Comme Antennas To Heaven’. NME said: “Galloping and frozen.”
15. Teenage Fanclub, ‘Howdy!’. NME said: “Classic Fanclub with no hard sell, just mile after mile of three-part harmonies and sun-bronzed chord progressions.”
14. Yo La Tengo, ‘And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out’. NME said: “Adult, confessional and certainly not rock ‘n’ roll.”
13. Lambchop,’ Nixon’. NME said: “The title hinted at lost dreams, but this was a vote for the good guys.”
12. Granddaddy,’ The Sophtware Slump’. NME said: “The finest LP made by men with beards.”
11. Radiohead, ‘Kid A’. NME said: “Embraced the accoutrements of obscurity with wilful glee.”
10. Kelis, ‘Kaleidoscope’. NME said: “Brimming with space-funk inspiration.”
9. Super Furry Animals, ‘Mwng’. NME said: “Their most coherent in tone, it was the band’s best album.”
8. Doves, ‘Lost Souls’. NME said: “Hailed as one of the first great debut albums of the millennium.”
7. Eminem, ‘The Marshall Mathers LP’. NME said: “The most fascinating pop superstar of our age.”
6. Coldplay, ‘Parachutes’. NME said: “Effortlessly moving and hugely popular at the same time.”
5. At The Drive-In, ‘Relationship Of Command’. NME said: “Proved that America could still be the brave, the bright, and the brilliant.”
4. Badly Drawn Boy, ‘The Hour Of Bewilderbeast’. NME said: “Homespun urban folk and pretty allegorical musings.”
3. PJ Harvey, ‘Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea’. NME said: “Polly’s most confident and sensual feast for almost a decade.”
2. Primal Scream, ‘Exterminator’. NME said: “Rarely has anger been so beautifully managed.”
1. Queens Of The Stone Age, ‘Rated R’. NME said: “The feel good hit of the summer that lasted all year.”

39 comments

Add comment

 
 
Alessandro del Palmero [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 16:42
I remember the early years of this decade being a bit barren music wise, but there's some stone cold classics on that list. Having Magnetic Fields so low down is a bit criminal, while how come an album with a big shout for being the best of the decade can only limp to a pathetic FORTY TWO! Oh, and Community Music is top five easily... That is all...
Ben Kenobi [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 17:24
It's Lost Souls and Parachutes for me.
SO WHAT [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 17:29
CUT COPY NEW ORDER BAD LIEUTENANT MYLO CHEMICAL BROTHERS COLDPLAY
Luke Lewis [Member] //November 6 2009 at 17:30
@So What - we're talking about 2000, not 2009.
pob [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 17:54
xtrmntr all the way for me
duki [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 18:00
Is this It? No love for the Strokes?
Ben [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 18:03
Eminem's The Marshall Mathers LP is not just the best album of 2000, it is the best of the decade. I'd go so far as to say it's as important as Nevermind or Nevermind the Bollocks, no other album has had the impact on popular culture this decade, or caused the stir that that album did when it came out.
Hayden [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 18:15
no manics?
jEBEND [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 18:30
Marshall Mathers LP made me care about music again.
nuge [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 18:43
i would def be keeping qotsa at no1 tho! classic album
Chimpachomp [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 18:52
where the hell is pearl jam's binaural?
davess [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 19:32
Rated R is still great actually although both SFTD and LTP were better, but it's At The Drive-In you really need to keep in any revised list because-speaking as someone who stumbled upon them in 2007/2008 by accident- it's still stunningly creative and fresh as anything.
Kirk [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 20:31
Definitely gotta be Relationship of Command! by At The Drive In!
Mark B [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 20:39
I still listen quite often to the QOTSA & Badly Drawn Boy discs on this list. I think they have aged quite well!
George-O [Visitor] //November 6 2009 at 22:28
Kid A all the way. One of the best records I've ever listened to. QOTSA are great too though :)
Alex [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 01:33
Bright Eyes - Fevers and Mirrors and Black Rebel Motorcycle Club - BRMC both seem to be missing, unless i have the years they were released wrong.
Lalala [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 02:26
De Stijl - White Stripes. Its a shame such a bluesy, exciting album tends to be forgotten since it was sandwiched between their self-titled debut and White Blood Cells.
Kerblah [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 03:33
Nice to see ATD-I on this list.
jf [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 11:31
A few omissions (and Sigur Rós and The Magnetic Fields are from 1999): Antony And The Johnsons - st The Avalanches - Since I Left You Luomo - Vocalcity New Pornographers - Mass Romantic Mansun - Little Kix Finley Quaye - Vanguard Modest Mouse - The Moon And Antarctica Eels - Daises Of The Galaxies The Dears - End Of A Hollywood Bedtime Story Phoenix - United Day One - Ordinary Man D'Angelo - Voodoo Morphine - The Night
RHHHHH [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 13:21
Heartbreaker by ryan adams is criminally low. One of the few 2000 albums that still holds up.
DJMC [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 13:40
List stands up pretty well. I think the badly drawn boy album deserves to be as high as it is - because his later career is diminishing returns, you can forget how perfectly made that album is. i guess ryan adams heartbreaker is an album now seen as a classic from that year that you missed at the time. 2000 wasn't a great year, generally. I'll be interested to look at your 2001 list again cos 2001, now that was a great year
Jason [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 16:13
I love The White Stripes... but come on... De Stijl is awful! Agree totally with Rated R at number one
Alex [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 17:01
People will hate me for saying it but Oasis S.O.T.S.O.G was for me the album of the year.....some great memories and contains some excellent music so dark and refreshing after the turd that was be here now.
Sandwell [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 17:23
Modest Mouse-The Moon and Antarctica. The greatest achivement of the western world! why do NME not give modest mouse any props?
Liam [Visitor] //November 7 2009 at 17:48
I have to say the whole top 10 (or 11) have aged incredibly well, although maybe Kid A should be higher.
Spencer [Visitor] //November 8 2009 at 01:06
Silent Alarm.
Jenny [Visitor] //November 8 2009 at 12:20
duki - Is This It was released in 2001. Although if it was 2000, it would've easily made Top 5..
neil [Visitor] //November 9 2009 at 10:48
yeah, but at the time parachutes actaully sounded "fresh". and kid a sounded a bit befuddled. parachutes was a good little indie album, i always thought. we didnt know at that time they'd turn into u2. i didnt like kid a, that much, and while the muso in me tries to apprecuate a little more these days, i still wouldnt rate it higher than parachutes - which was my favourite album of the year. and im nto ashamed to admit it.
noel [Visitor] //November 9 2009 at 10:54
...that or xtrmntr. theres that dumb mbv arkestra track on that album which really spoils it. sounds like my cat being raped.
[Visitor] //November 9 2009 at 12:34
EXTERMINATOR - THE BEST ALBUM OF ALL TIME, IS AS RELEVANT TODAY AS IT WAS THEN TEN YEARS AGO, FOR ONCE THE NME GOT IT SPOT ON, WELL DONE. At that point in time music was fresh and dangerous, thought we were on the verge of a new music revelution and then along came all that Razor light shite
john [Visitor] //November 9 2009 at 13:58
the great eastern by the delgados was my album of the year then and still now. also love nixon, sophtware slump, the blue trees and exterminator.
Gary [Visitor] //November 9 2009 at 14:12
Easy............The Beatles...1
[Visitor] //November 9 2009 at 14:50
The Hour of Bewilderbeast and Xtrmntr were the two big albums for me that year, I think they're both still great now. Kid A has got better with time, but back then nobody seemed to quite get it. Tom McRae's eponymous debut seems to be the one missing from the list in my opinion, and I have a feeling Warning by Green Day came out that year too; a brilliant guitar pop abum! However, this list has no credibility anyway: Outkast's Stankonia only at 42?????
walks [Visitor] //November 9 2009 at 15:23
Shows what a poor year 2000 was with that list. Rated R is a half decent album but imo really shouldn't be number one with a severe lack of killer tracks. And how is heartbreaker only 45!!! It could easily be justified to be put in the top 10 albums of the decade (something which your other mag uncut did) and holds some great songs such as 'to be young', 'come pick me up' and 'oh my sweet carolina'. Apart from 4 or 5 albums in radiohead, eminem, primal scream, ryan adams and possibly doves and coldplay, it really was not the best of 2000's years with the following year picking up dramatically.
Rhys Laverty [Visitor] //November 14 2009 at 18:43
Not my favourite album or band by any means, but the NME would have died by 2003 if The Strokes hadn't released Is This It? and essentially created the vast majority of the indie scene that the NME covers. Shocked but not appalled at its omission.
VVatson [Visitor] //November 15 2009 at 00:51
XTRMNTR and PJ's Stories both still fantastic today. As for the slight embarassment looking back on the list, I suppose it's all about both the evolution of a band or an album's perception so you can't really be too negative. Who knows, in ten years the Horrors could be singing boyband ballads on stools and making guest appearances on ITV. I'll stop now to keep myself shuddering!
jesse [Visitor] //November 16 2009 at 04:32
@ Visitor - exterminator is the sound of a band attempting to sound new and different; it's not like there aren't songs or good sounds, it's just all a bit of a pose or put-on, like just about everything that Primal Scream do (though occasionally they do a genius single or two - Country Girl...Come Together...). Exterminator is the triumph of concept over soul, in other words; but sometimes 't Scream do something with a bit of proper heart that has something beneath the pose. As for Razor light shite...weirdly, there is something good about Razorlight...though maybe 'all the other shite' you refer to (whatever it is) really is shite. Razorlight are, maybe, the slightly pop act that some people like, that it's ok to like (even if some slag them off); something good about them anyway.
Idz [Visitor] //November 17 2009 at 16:46
Kid A is the best album of the noughties.
Gaz [Visitor] //November 18 2009 at 12:32
Exterminator was when I suddenly woke up in 2000. Everything seemed so silent that year.

This post has 1 feedback awaiting moderation...

Leave a comment:

 
 

Note: HTML tags are not allowed
 

<< Previous post: Stuck On Repeat - Why 2009 Is Exactly The Same As 1983

Next post: 10 Tracks You Have To Hear This Week - Yeasayer, Jamie T, Lil Wayne >>

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox: