First For Music News

NME Festivals Blog 2009 - Festival action, all year round -  Festival action, all year round

By Luke Lewis

Posted on 11/07/09 at 05:00:33 pm

It takes a special breed of rock musician to compose an opera that you’d willingly sit through without having first been bound and gagged. Damon Albarn managed it with ‘Monkey: Journey To The West’. Conceivably, someone like Nick Cave could pull it off.

The author has to be someone extravagantly gifted, whose previous output already has a touch of the intellectual/avant-garde. Not everyone falls into this category. If Peanut from Kaiser Chiefs penned a libretto, or Slayer guitarist Kerry King, you’d be instantly wary.

With Rufus Wainwright, however, it’s hardly much of a stretch. His music has always had an intricately orchestral, rococo quality - so when it transpired he’d penned a French-language opera, no-one was shocked. It’s not like he’d gone digi-punk, or released an EP of Lethal Bizzle covers.

continued...

Besides, it’s an impressive achievement. Writing an opera is high-up on the list of things only freakishly talented people can do, like being able to tell the difference between ‘Nuts’ and ‘Zoo’ magazines, or completing 'Killzone 2' on the highest difficulty setting.

Even so, there’s still a stigma attached to opera, a whiff of upper-middle-class pretension. It’s a difficult subject to discuss without sounding like an outrageous, shiraz-glugging ponce.

Indeed, when I told my friends I was going to Manchester to see ‘Prima Donna’, they could have been no more appalled had I suddenly sounded a fox-hunting trumpet, or started reciting the collected works of Noel Coward.

Well, it’s their loss - because ‘Prima Donna’ is dazzlingly brilliant.

Telling the self-reflexive tale of Regina Saint Laurent, an unlucky-in-love, Maria Callas-style retired soprano, as she prepares to return to the stage, the opera has a sparse narrative arc that enables Wainwright to meditate on the redemptive power of music (surely a subject close to his heart, given the crushing, drug-induced depths he’s plumbed in his own life) as well as the heartbreaking transience of creativity.

The bleak message is this: as an artist you may have one hit, one brief flicker of greatness - but you’ll then spend the rest of your life trying in vain to recapture it.

Counterbalancing the desolation of the plot, however, is an extraordinary visual verve, courtesy of set designer Antony McDonald. The whole thing looks sensational.

Even with my limited experience of opera - I’ve only ever seen Tosca (or was it Turandot? It was the one with an enormous amount of rape and death, ie every opera ever) - I can tell you that the staging was jaw-droppingly innovative, an ever-shifting backdrop that variously represented the heroine’s suffocating boudoir, a blood-spattered kitchen, and the Paris skyline, gloriously irradiated by fireworks.

The only letdown is that ‘Prima Donna’ didn’t feature more scenes from Wainwright’s own, drama-packed life. The going-blind-on-crystal-meth scene would have been a real hoot.

Still, Wainwright loomed large in other ways. Ever the shrinking violet, before the show he ‘did’ the red carpet three times before taking his seat. It was hard to miss him - he turned up wearing a top hat and twirling a silver-capped cane.

Indeed, I was left reeling at how someone can be so bursting with self-regard, yet still be so enormously likeable. If Brandon Flowers behaved like this, you’d think he was a total wanker.

Yet Wainwright has earned the right to live out his Guiseppe Verdi fantasies. The fact he can not only make this grand folly work artistically, but also achieve it with his cool and affability intact, tells you a great deal about this remarkable artist’s charmed existence.

20 comments

Add comment

 
 
June O'Keefe [Visitor] //July 11 2009 at 19:01
Who could ever doubt that the totally brilliant Rufus would fail to succeed with his first ever Opera!
Dave Hunt [Visitor] //July 11 2009 at 19:52
Let's see it in Tampa!
[Visitor] //July 11 2009 at 19:57
Even so, there’s still a stigma attached to opera, a whiff of upper-middle-class pretension. It’s a difficult subject to discuss without sounding like an outrageous, shiraz-glugging ponce????????? Fuck you. I love opera. Real opera. Otello, Don Carlos, Rigoletto. I love the Sex Pistols, the Beatles, Nirvana, The BEach Boys, Michael Jackson. I am 51 and I....I.....I......arrrrghhhhh
Joanie [Visitor] //July 11 2009 at 21:12
I'm one of the many "Rufusettes" and I'm off to see Rufus' opera shortly. Can't wait. He's enormously talented, clearly extremely nervous at the prospect of his premiere for the opera. It looks as though he's pulled it off - again!
Nutella [Visitor] //July 12 2009 at 23:22
No, Rufus, you didn't pull it off, I'm very sad to say. It was so BORING. And it wasn't clear whether you were trying to write a proper opera or take the pee out of opera. I was expecting more from one so talented.
Tim Swinton [Visitor] //July 13 2009 at 10:38
I saw it yesterday and it wasn't to my taste I'm afraid. It didn't seem to have much change of pace in a hefty amount of stage-time, and though I'm prepared to believe I'm wrong about its merits, the audience reaction at the end, even allowing for the usual opera-y hysteria, smacked of the Emperor's New Clothes, nobody wanted to be the first to say they didn't get it. And that was it for me - I just didn't get it. The characters were either shameless caricatures, or just dull and the story was melodrama and bathos combined. But I don't get out much and could easily be wrong. Did anyone else see it? But given all that, and judging by his personal appearance, Mr Wainwright is a hell of a showman! Good for him.
anon [Visitor] //July 13 2009 at 11:48
yes obviously you dont get out much ----
Chris Bell [Visitor] //July 13 2009 at 12:37
What I meant to say was, how dare you assume that all opera goers and lovers are as you describe......Rufus is a songwiter and performer. A very good one. Nothing more. Modern opera is insufferably pretentious and forced and..............well not opera!
Maxine Railton [Visitor] //July 13 2009 at 13:57
I agree with you, Tim. As an enormous Rufus (and opera)fan, I really wanted to be able to rave about it but found myself wanting......something. There was so little light and shade that I wasn't swept away and some of it was just ludicrous. Highlight of the day was getting Rufus' autograph as I think he's an immensely talented musician but, sadly, this was too big an undertaking even for one so gifted.
Krista [Visitor] //July 13 2009 at 19:14
Would it be too much to ask to find a reviewer who has some experience with opera? (It might be too much to ask to find someone with experience of opera AND Wainwright, but that would have been the best combination).
Dinky [Visitor] //July 14 2009 at 02:27
Colorado!! Bring it to Colorado!!!
Luke Lewis [Member] //July 14 2009 at 09:48
@Kritsa - believe it or not the ranks of NME are not bursting with opera experts
Prima Donna [Visitor] //July 14 2009 at 12:02
I'd been of the opinion that the NME has been going off the boil for a fair few years now. However, it's great to see a review for Prima Donna and I don't think you necessarily need an opera expert to do this. It's a modern opera that can be appreciated by more that the alleged opera elite. That said, if you're not really into much orchestral or operatic music, you're not going to like just because it was penned by Rufus. I thought it was fantastic for many reasons: vocal and orchestral scores, humour, cast, performance, biographical aspects of Rufus....There doesn't have to be such a gap between the orchestral and the non-orchestral musical worlds and if all Rufus does is to narrow that gap slightly, he's worthy of praise.
Tim Swinton [Visitor] //July 14 2009 at 12:40
Let's hear from Joanie - you were just off to see it - what did you think?
Bryn Maddick [Visitor] //July 15 2009 at 10:02
Fanstastic set, fantastic writing, great singing, but pretentious beyond scale. A classic case of art for art(ists) sake.
[Visitor] //July 15 2009 at 23:11
Unlike his albums, there was no stand out tunes and the lyrics were shit
Meredith Aska McBride [Visitor] //July 16 2009 at 18:40
Interesting review and one of the few positive ones I've read...most critics in the States panned it. Another perspective on the debut: meredithaskamcbride.wordpress.com
Prima Donna [Visitor] //July 17 2009 at 12:43
'Visitor' - Unlike his albums, this was an opera and therefore your opinion that the "lyrics were shit" is a bit naive. If people complain when we get something genuinely different, exciting and brave, we'll find that we just get the boring, dull and safe i.e., Andrew Lloyd Webber, Simon Cowell and John Barrowman. For Christ's sake, people, get a grip. And as for those critics who found it all a bit egotistical, did they not know the name of the opera before they attended? It was done in good humour and with a better use of orchestration than most 'pop stars' could bring to the table. I'd quite happily go back for a second viewing.
[Visitor] //July 20 2009 at 23:06
Prima Donna: take a chill pill dude! It's not a G.S.C.E exam question.
[Visitor] //October 20 2009 at 12:32
"If Brandon Flowers behaved like this, you’d think he was a total wanker." ...am I missing something? Singing talent aside(bar terrible Hallelujah cover) is he not just a poncey wanker? Or is the fact he was fucked up on drugs his saving grace?

This post has 1 feedback awaiting moderation...

Leave a comment:

 
 

Note: HTML tags are not allowed
 

<< Previous post: T In The Park 2009: Who Are You Looking Forward To Seeing?

Next post: T In The Park - How Was It For You? >>

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox: