Green Day win lawsuit over artwork rights

The band are not liable for using LA artist's work in their live shows

Photo: Next Previous

Photo Gallery: Green Day

Green Day have been cleared of violating an artist's rights by a Californian court, Reuters reports.

Los Angeles illustrator Dereck Seltzer designed the image Scream Icon, which features an "anguished, contorted face" in 2003. It has appeared on posters and street art, including on a brick wall on LA's Sunset Boulevard, from where Green Day adapted the image for use in a video backdrop during their 2009 tour.

Using the artwork during the song 'East Jesus Nowhere', the band made few changes to the image, save for covering it with a red spray-painted cross. Despite this, the ninth US Circuit Court Of Appeals In California rejected Seltzer's claims that the punk rock band had used his artwork without his permission. Calling it a "close and difficult case", Circuit Judge Diarmuid O'Scannlain said their use of the image was "transformative and not overly commercial".

"With the spray-painted cross, in the context of a song about the hypocrisy of religion, surrounded by religious iconography, [the] video backdrop using Scream Icon conveys new information, new aesthetics, new insights and understandings that are plainly distinct from those of the original piece," he wrote of his decision.

The fact that the image was not present in any of Green Day’s merchandise or promotional material and Seltzer's own testimony that the value of his work was not affected weighed in the band’s favour, according to O'Scannlain.

The decision could now make it easier for performers to incorporate artwork into their live shows, provided artwork is not copied or has its value diminished.

Read More On This Artist

Green Day Merchandise
More News
Tobias Jesso Jr. shares new song 'Without You' - listen
#thankszane trends as Arctic Monkeys, Biffy Clyro and more pay tribute to Zane Lowe
Metallica's Lars Ulrich says band's new album is 'pretty close' to being written
50 Cent claims Suge Knight 'wanted to kill Dr Dre' in the 1990s
Antemasque throw boiling water at fans during festival performance
Björk to play first European gig since release of new album at Manchester International Festival
Left-wing writer Owen Jones to support Paloma Faith in London and Brighton
Palma Violets play raucous London show to close NME Awards Tour 2015 with Austin, Texas
Secondary ticket websites promise to become more transparent
The Strokes deny rumours that they will perform at Glastonbury this year
Method Man on Wu-Tang Clan's 'Once Upon A Time In Shaolin': 'Fuck that...
Pharrell Williams: 'I was inspired by Miley Cyrus, not Marvin Gaye, when I wrote...
Major Lazer premiere new track 'Lean On', featuring DJ Snake and MØ - listen
Brandon Flowers, Norah Jones and Best Coast's Bethany Cosentino to play at Brian Wilson...
Noel Gallagher mixes new tracks and old favourites at Dublin's 3Arena
Florence + The Machine debut three new songs at intimate London show
Travis Barker says Tom DeLonge 'doesn't like punk music' and that it 'was a...
SoundCloud claim to have paid $1 million to artists and labels since August
James Murphy shares 'Only The Stars Above Welcome Me Home' from Noah Baumbach film score
Chris Brown’s girlfriend dumps him via Twitter
Madonna calls Kanye West a 'brilliant madman' and 'beautiful mess'
David Gilmour announces first UK and Europe tour for nine years

More News

Comments

Please login to add your comment.

Latest Tickets - Booking Now
 
Know Your NME
 

 
NME Store & Framed Prints
Inside NME.COM