NME News

Emo fans defend their music against suicide claims

My Chemical Romance

My Chemical Romance

Fans say their music not to blame for Hannah Bond death

Emo fans have contacted NME.COM to defend their music against claims it inspired 13 year-old Hannah Bond to commit suicide.

Roger Sykes, the coroner who gave the verdict of suicide yesterday (May 7), suggested that the fact that Bond was an obsessive fan of such music (My Chemical Romance being mentioned in particular) was linked to her death.

The inquest heard that Bond had discussed with friends the "glamour" of suicide, and was obsessed with My Chemical Romance.

However while most fans accepted that Bond's death was a tragedy, they rejected the coroner's conclusion that "the emo overtones concerning death and associating it with glamour I find very disturbing".

NME.COM user Time For Something Bibical said: "My heart goes out to her family, but you don't get 'sucidial' just solely by listening to 'emo' music, there are always deeper reasons and connections.

"My Chemical Romance aren't very emo to be honest, their last album had quite a lot about hope - eg 'Welcome To The Black Parade' and 'Famous Last Words'. I listen to emo music, it doesn't make me sad or anything."

Neamychem added: "MCR is a band that wants to save people's lives, NOT destroy them."

luvmark also questioned the coroner's verdict. He said: "I find it disgusting that small-minded people would assume that music has that much of an influence, that someone would kill themselves because of it.

"The idea of suicide has always been glamourised, even in films, but apparently it's easier to blame someone who has been slated in the past. I listen to My Chem, as do many of my friends, and we are happy people with happy lives."

Comments (5)

Add a comment

mnd5x7 

May 8, 2008

i don't think that MCR was the reason for her death, but do you really think that a 13 year old girl can fully understand some of the lyrics? I'm saying she obviously had deeper causes for it, but maybe misiterpreting some lyrics didn't help.

Tafferel 

May 9, 2008

this is a pathetic backlash, remember marilyn manson was blaimed for the columbine disaster! its an easy target and scapegoat. that coroner is an idiot.

Saii. 

May 9, 2008

It's not fair to blame them, It was completely her own choice and I don't believe lyrics can make her want to take her own life.

TheBooshIsLoose 

May 9, 2008

I think it is ridiculous to blame MCR for this girls death. If you listen to the lyrics you will see there is nothing in there that promotes suicide and even if there was, no right minded person would listen to it a think "i'm going to kill myself now." I don't think anyone can say that there is any link between emo and suicide, it's just a myth and emo has become an easy target for ridicule like this just because emo is supposed to be 'emotional.' But the bottom line is emotional does not mean suicide, emo does not mean suicide and MCR is NOT emo. I looooove MCR more than anyone i know and i am the happiest and least suicidal person i know.

MCR_addict 

May 9, 2008

thans bs they save not destroy

Add your comment

NME Alerts

Get NME news delivered direct to your desktop. Find out more

Please sign in

Forgot your password?

Register with MyNME

Every Tuesday

  • Breaking News stories
  • All you need to know about the week's NME magazine
  • Live, Album and Track reviews
  • Tip offs about the most important Gigs
  • All the latest NME.COM video exclusives

Every Friday

  • NME.COM's free mini-magazine
  • Gig listings for the weekend
  • All the most important Album and Track reviews
  • The week's biggest News stories
  • Competitions - with exclusive music prizes
  • plus loads more!

In The Magazine

This Week's Issue
  • Breaking music news and award-winning photography
  • Exclusive interviews with the world's most exciting bands
  • In depth reviews of the week's most important music releases and live events
  • The UK's biggest gig listings guide
  • Subscribe today and get 1/3rd off NME