First For Music News

Paul McCartney says Pirate Bay verdict was 'fair'

'If you get on a bus, you've got to pay,' says ex-Beatle

Sir Paul McCartney has said that he believes the verdict handed down to four people linked with the The Pirate Bay website was "fair".

Four men were sentenced to a year in jail and fined £2.4 million for their involvement with the file-sharing website, being convicted of copyright infringement in Stockholm last week (April 16).

The former Beatle told BBC Newsbeat that he believed that music should be paid for.

Speaking about the case, he said, "If you get on a bus you've got to pay. And I think it's fair, you should pay your ticket."

He suggested that websites such as The Pirate Bay were harmful to young bands.

"The problem is you get a lot of young bands coming up and some of them aren't going to last forever," he said. "So if they have a massive hit that's going to pay their mortgage forever.

"They're going to feed the children on that and if they don't get that money, if they don't see that money, I think it's a bit of a pity."

One of the website's founders, Peter Sunde Kolmsioppi, has suggested that he will refuse to pay the fine imposed on him as part of the verdict.

 

More News:

 

Comments (6)

edwardsoperation.com 

Apr 20, 2009

McCartney is right. Why should music be different from any other product or commodity that costs money (and a lot of it) to produce? Just because digital music and the internet make theft of music easy, it does not make it cool. So, to all you file sharers out there stealing the products of peoples' hard work, I'd like to say, "Fuck off and burn in hell."

Beatle_Matt 

Apr 20, 2009

I think the big problem is that the music industry has always struggled and always fought technology instead of embracing it and finding new ways to market itself.This is the same thing that happened in the 80's when the RIAA thought that people copying cassettes and giving them to friends would end the music biz...

underclasshero 

Apr 20, 2009

right back at you edwardsoperation.com you prick!if record labels didn't charge stupid prices for CD's and downloads and actually gave the artists fair amounts of the money made then more people would buy music and other things shared on the internet. Your better off going to a gig or buying some of the artists merch if you really want to help as they keep far more of the money for such things.

rept0n 

Apr 20, 2009

...but if you are merely 'signposting' to a bus that 'some' people might get on and then not pay for THEIR tickets... you shouldn't be fined £2.4 million.

never_stop_shaving 

Apr 20, 2009

ya know, mark david chapman really should have put more effort into taking out ALL of the beatles....

ed2005 

Apr 21, 2009

Right on, rept0n, Beatle_Matt, underclasshero. edwardsoperation.com's remarks are more offensive than McCartney's -oh, and I run a record label. The music industry has exploited many, and it's a bit sodding rich, that the Beatles albums are all at full price. You've made your money, written some good songs, so stop exploiting people.

Tell us what you think. We’ll print the best responses in the NME letters page each week.

Listen to full tracks now. Users outside the UK can hear 30-second clips of each song.

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox: