NME News

Illegal downloaders could be banned from internet

Proposed new law could revoke online privileges

People who download music illegally could be banned from the internet under plans currently being considered by the UK government.

Ministers are examining a scheme that would mean anyone in the UK would be denied access to their internet service provider if they were caught with files containing pirated copies of songs and films.

The proposals appeared in a leaked draft Green Paper – a consultation document issued by the government when it is considering new legislation – and would involved UK internet users being given "three strikes" before having their online access terminated.

First offenders would be warned by email, then their accounts would be suspended after which they contracts with their service provider would be cancelled.

Internet providers who failed to uphold the proposed law could be prosecuted too.

According to The Times, some ISPs had already been looking into a voluntary code, although there has been no agreement so far as no decision on how to settle disputes has been arranged.

Although attempts to come to an agreement are still ongoing, the Green Paper says the government will "move to legislate to require internet service providers to take action on illegal file-sharing."

Responding to the early draft proposals leaking, a spokesman for the Department for Culture, Media And Sport told The Times:

"Early drafts of our creative economy programme document were circulated to stakeholders for comment. The content and proposals for the strategy have been significantly developed since then and a comprehensive plan to bolster the UK's creative industries will be published shortly. We will not comment on the content of the leaked document."

Music industry body IFPI welcomed the possible idea though, insisting ISPs needed to take responsibility for illegal downloads.

“The tide of opinion is flowing in favour of ISP responsibility," said John Kennedy chairman and chief executive of IFPI. "News of the UK government’s proposed consultation paper is very welcome and we hope for swift action from ISPs to disconnect persistent serious copyright infringers."

Comments (15)

Add a comment

nicktherockstar 

Feb 12, 2008

9 out of 10 new bands get big from the illegal sharing of their small scale singles/demos etc, I for one would be buying way less music if the option of checking out a full album before buying was taken away. I would also be going to far fewer gigs, mainly the smaller up and coming bands gigs because I wouldnt know any of the songs like I would now from leaks etc before they put out their full albums. its too far, I agree something has to be done but this is not the answer, waking up to the ways of the moden music buyer is needed, full... maybe time limited free downloads of albums maybe. you get it for 7-14 days then it expires?

MrMoon1975 

Feb 12, 2008

I dont download coz quite frankly, I dont have the time or the knowhow to bother about it, but I have no sympathy for record companies losing money due to downloads. After all, they have been ripping off us, the music buyers, for years. The record companies have been pocketing all the profits, Most of which gets spent on ridiculous and unnecessary expenditure and over indulgence by A&R and marketing men, especially throughout the 80's and 90's.

it costs a couple of pence to make a CD yet we have to pay £14.99!!! No thank you. All we do is line peoples pockets

As for the artists, they are making far too much money for what they are doing, which are essentially, second rate albums with a shelf life of about a week!!

HunterHawes13 

Feb 12, 2008

"1984 knocking on your door
will you let it come
will you let it run your life"

ldngigs 

Feb 12, 2008

Well with myspace and other sites these days its easy to listen to music if you have the internet, so its not too much of a problem. Soon enough most bands will be trying new methods of 'selling' like Radiohead.

polovw 

Feb 12, 2008

hi
i am portuguese. and a cd over here cust around 18 euros and the minimum wage its around 420 euros...thats why most people download music for free or buy copies for 4 euros or less its impossible to buy cds at that price. i buy some but i dont have kids or a mortagage to pay. people have right to culture. life its to expensive over here.

the_royal_wee 

Feb 12, 2008

mty moon 1975: "it costs a couple of pence to make a CD yet we have to pay £14.99!!!" Have you not heard of distribution, marketing, packaging and advertising costs? designers don't design sleeves for free. they don't turn up in music stores by magic. you have no clue what you are talking about. and yes, i download illegally sometimes.

Spooke 

Feb 12, 2008

It will be impossible to enforce. It will never make it in to law.

Guitarist202 

Feb 12, 2008

It's very simple, it is illegal to download music without the band/artist saying you can. So if these new up and coming bands need to show off their songs, then they can make available for free download its as simple as that

Love will Tear us Apart 

Feb 13, 2008

I understand they want to clamp down on people who just download everything, but sometimes with obscure and deleted records, the only way to hear it is to download it illegally, as none of the legal mp3 sites have them. Anyway mp3's are shit, souless, even high quality bit rate mp3's, and i'll keep buying cd's and vinyl as long as they are still available (sod the digital era, give me a turntable anyday) and the added bonus with cds is the artwork, the liner notes etc take time to shop around online, in bargain bins, sales, charity shops when buying albums, don't pay the first price you see, and you'll get more for your money.

stephenayres 

Feb 13, 2008

There were 1.2 billion illegal downloads in Spain alone last year. How are internet companies going to stop the millions of people who do this? It would be almost impossible to enforce and they would go out of business!

Dazza30 

Feb 13, 2008

i download music. i'm a student and when i have a job im earning very little so it's the only way for me to listen to new albums, most of the time i do try and buy an album i have downloaded but its so hard to find the money. i think alot more bands need to sell albums like Radiohead to get the downloading generation into buying albums and the band make more money because no money is put into Cd's cases, artwork and the actual physical side of an album.

clockwork robots 

Feb 13, 2008

even though this law wouldn't affect me in Canada, it still seems a bit silly. I mean, artists make more off touring and merch anyway, at least with downloading and file sharing they're able to get their music out to more people and potential fans who'll buy those gig tickets and t-shirts.

Loafite 

Feb 13, 2008

I think it is estimated that some 5 million people download illegally in the UK. Does anyone think that Internet providers will actually embrace a law that could theoretically cut their customer base by that amount?

underclasshero 

Feb 13, 2008

An average CD costs around £10, however to actually make to obtain the materials, create the CD, print the covers it only costs a few pence, if the money was going to the artists then i would be more prepared to pay this every time i wanted a CD, however the fact is i know of NO-ONE AT ALL that hasn't at some point downloaded a song or a cd, been sent an album over MSN or anything like that, people should just buy an artists merch or go watch them live, that way they get more of the money. Trying to stop people from illegally downloading will be impossible without internet providers losing over 75% of there customers, and it just won't happen.

kylienut 

Feb 14, 2008

When I was young, free and single, I spent most of my spare cash on CDs and videos (if you remeber what they are).
I have over 500 CDs and had (until I replaced them with DVDs) about the same number of videos.
At an average price of £10, that's about £10,000 I've spent on music and film.
Many years later, I am maried with children, mortgage, car to run, etc. there's no way I have the spare cash to go out and by every CD I like. Being able to download (whether legally or illegally) allows one to listen to music that is out of one's normal habit and occasionally be pleasantly surprised by what they hear. I would then go and buy an album knowing that I liked it so obtaining music in this way does encourage listeners' musical tastes to broaden. For instance I listened to the "Arcade Fire" and "Band of Horses" albums recently - I would never have even thought about just going out and buying them on the off chance I would like them.

Add your comment

NME Alerts

Get NME news delivered direct to your desktop. Find out more

Please sign in

Forgot your password?

Register with MyNME

Every Tuesday

  • Breaking News stories
  • All you need to know about the week's NME magazine
  • Live, Album and Track reviews
  • Tip offs about the most important Gigs
  • All the latest NME.COM video exclusives

Every Friday

  • NME.COM's free mini-magazine
  • Gig listings for the weekend
  • All the most important Album and Track reviews
  • The week's biggest News stories
  • Competitions - with exclusive music prizes
  • plus loads more!

In The Magazine

This Week's Issue
  • The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • Agenda-setting news and fiery comment
  • Must-read interviews with the planet's hottest bands
  • Hundreds of UK gigs listed every week
  • Unrivalled access to the artists that matter
  • Subscribe today and get 1/3rd off NME