First For Music News

BPI hit back at claims music piracy is 'like stealing soap from a hotel room'

Recent UK government comments infuriate the music industry

The British Phonographic Industry (BPI) has hit back at claims by a UK government minister that online music piracy is akin to stealing the soap from a hotel room.

David Lammy, the Intellectual Property Minister made the comparison in an interview with The Times, printed yesterday (January 26). He also said he believed initial plans put forward by the government to arrest guilty downloaders were unworkable.

BPI Director of Public Affairs Richard Mollet responded to Lammy's claims with scorn, saying the British music industry would be "insulted" by the analogy, reports Billboard.biz.

"It shows an incredible lack of understanding [of the relationship] between music and illegal file-sharing from the minister in charge of intellectual property," Mollet said.

"We are appalled to see him falsely raising the prospect of arresting people in their bedrooms and fail to see what place this has in the discussion."

A new government paper addressing online music piracy, 'Digital Britain', is due to be published on January 29.
 

More News:

 

Comments (6)

Add a comment

markiechops 

Jan 27, 2009

That's not a particularly accurate analogy; most soap is actually useful.

Moz_1983 

Jan 27, 2009

BPI, you are fighting a losing battle you deserve to lose. You have failed to shift your business model to adapt to new technology and modern trends and now you're paying for it. Years of charging extortionate prices for cds has come round to bite you in the ass, and you thoroughly deserve it.

NicholaCarr 

Jan 27, 2009

Go Moz_1983!!! Couldn't have put it better myself. We'd better watch out now though Moz, they'll be trying to check out what we're upto somehow or another.

wowzer555 

Jan 27, 2009

the BPI are not entirely to blame. The labels deserve it, they are the ones that have generated an inflated world where money was pissed away like rainwater and now they have no answer to it. You always have to remember that in the end of the day piracy hurts the bands and musicians the most. people often say... oh music costs nothing to make, what difference does it make? well.. ive been a musician in the industry for 10 years and I've yet to meet anyone whos made an album/single/ep for free. so why should it be treated as such by the online community? and as for the government? well a multi billion pound industry has pretty much died over night on their watch. nothing new there then.lol.

Cheeseandonion 

Jan 27, 2009

I don't wish to be rude, but I do get the impression that David Lammy isn't the brightest bulb on the tree.

radnz 

Jan 28, 2009

Moz1983...you obviously are a serial illegal downloader and dont have a clue about the music industry and how it all works. Im not going to blab on about it here but at least wowzer555 has a better idea. Sure, CDs are cheap to reproduce BUT the music recorded on them can take bloody ages to write, arrange & record and will cost shitloads in studio time etc. These musicians you love (or hate) spend a huge amount of time, effort and money to come up with these amazing tunes that we all love and get huge enjoyment out of them, and basically you tell them to fuck off and want them to give it to you for free. Thats just Fucking disrespectful and shortsighted. Support these musicians by buying their cds, legal downloads, merchandise, and go and see them kick ass live if you want some decent bands to continue and not through in the towel and get a day job.

Add your comment

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox:

Various Artists CDs