First for music news

Edinburgh Cas Rock

...worth diddly-squat when your tunes can't cut the mustard.

Edinburgh Cas Rock

'From here on in it's a riot', yelps Action Spectacular's scrupulously scrawled, perfectly lit backdrop, and you have to admire their dogged self-belief.

From their immaculately contrived conception, the Sheffield youngsters have been at pains to disassociate themselves from the current say-nothing, do-nothing indie brigade. And, through a series of incendiary, admirably abstract press missives, it's a ploy that's worked; earning the fivesome a respectable notoriety. But though an ounce of art-pop braggadocio can be worth its weight in Toploader albums it is, unfortunately, worth diddly-squat when your tunes can't cut the mustard. And the Spectacular's, largely, don't.

Although the occasional title ('Roxy Music') and a winning penchant for all things bleepy suggest a band champing at the synth-pop bit, Action Spectacular's divining rod, on tonight's evidence, stalled at the evolutionary black spot that was baggy.

So we get 'Stand Up', an eager but strangely flatfooted take on Happy Mondays' rubber-jowled groove. And we get 'Music In The Sun' - a frenzied deconstruction of The Doors' 'Peace Frog' that flaps like Northside in flippers. Both of which are rather cute and all but, clearly, the Spectacular's exacting vision has failed to stretch as far as their music. A little less detail, then, and a whole lot more attention to the wider picture, and the arrogance may be justified yet.

Rate this gig

Average rating

Be the first to rate this gig

NEW! For the latest music videos and backstage interviews, check out our brand new sister site, NME Video.

More
Comments

Comments do not always reflect the views of NME, or IPC Media, for guidelines visit our Ts & Cs page

Featured Videos
Latest Tickets
NME Store & Framed Prints
Most Read Reviews
Popular This Week
Twitter
New Issue Out Now
Inside NME.COM
 
Newsletter

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox

On NME.COM Today