BBC Latest Rock & Indie Reviews: Emma Pollock - The Law of Large Numbers
"Long-term fans of Pollock, and The Delgados, will find their expectations met."
September 12, 2005
With all the flavours on the emotional trolley, The Delgados still can't get past bittersweet....
6 / 10
After two LPs ('Domestiques' and 'Peloton') named after bicycling terminology, The Delgados have named their third album after a Glasgow dosshouse. Its stern facades keep watch over the inner sleeve, and the inhabitants' troubled spirits pass like a shiver through the album's darker tracks.
The group's ambitions are clearly high. It was recorded in upstate New York by friend of the glockenspiel Dave Fridmann. But while 'The Great Eastern' undoubtedly moves, even as it impresses, the album's grandeur - all swooping cellos, dulcimers, clarinets, flugelhorns, vibraphones - only lays bare The Delgados' limitations as unorthodox pop athletes.
You would have imagined that by now, Glasgow's most comprehensively strung would have learned to let shy tunes like 'Accused Of Stealing' unfold of their own accord. Instead, every graceful shoot here is instantly fenced off by woodwind, then locked in a great cat's cradle of fussy arrangements. Their cause isn't helped by Emma Pollock and Alun Woodward's two-note Swanney whistle melodies, whose very basic charms are no match for the rabid symphonics queuing up to overwhelm them.
With all the flavours on the emotional trolley, The Delgados still can't get past bittersweet. And for all their enthusiasm for music's vast palette, their songs all come out in monochrome. Like the institution with which it shares its name, 'The Great Eastern' feels haunted by opportunities missed.
NEW! For the latest music videos and backstage interviews, check out our brand new sister site, NME Video.
"Long-term fans of Pollock, and The Delgados, will find their expectations met."
"Mercury Rev's influential orchestral rock landmark has been reissued in 2xCD form, with an extra disc of demos and rarities. The arrival of Deserter's Songs on the nascent V2 label in 1998 was a brow-raiser in and of itself. The band had flirted with symphonic flourishes and sentimental..."
You may need to upgrade your Flash Player
You can download the latest flash plugin here.
If you have installed flash but keep getting this message:
1. Try to bypass flash plugin detection here.
2. Ensure you have javascript enabled in your browser.
3. Try using Firefox
Listen to more Free Music at we7.com
Comments do not always reflect the views of NME, or IPC Media, for guidelines visit our Ts & Cs page