First For Music News

Dirty Projectors: 'Rise Above'

'A reimagining of Black Flag’s seminal 1981 punk rock album'

The fourth album from Brooklyn’s David Longstreth, aka Dirty Projectors, is what he calls a “reimagining” of Black Flag’s seminal 1981 punk rock album ‘Damaged’, but realised with violins, samples and vocals seemingly teased from Antony Hegarty’s throat while a football’s repeatedly bounced against his larynx. Although it’s got about as much resemblance to the original as Beth Ditto does to Pete Burns, you’ve got to applaud his creativity. Alas, it’s unlikely that the applause will stretch to actually wanting to listen as the looping metallic effects, heart-attack drums and seemingly played-backwards female vocals confuse more than impress. Still, it’s fun hearing lyrics such as “This fucking city is run by pigs/They take away the rights from all the kids” sung through snooty nostrils, and you get the impression Longstreth had a chuckle too.

Jamie Fullerton

5 out of 10
 

More Reviews of Dirty Projectors - The

 
 

Comments (2)

Add a comment

pappygold 

Oct 23, 2007

wow. looks like you got it right again, NME.
how awesome are the wombats?

AdamFelman 

Oct 31, 2007

I hate to say this, but NME, you are very, very wrong. On having seen The Projectors live, felt my over-extended jaw collide with the floor and gone back to see them as soon as they arrived within a 100-mile radius of my house, I can safely say without fear of contradiction that they are one of the best bands on the planet. Yes, it's arty, and yes, it's extraordinarily strange. But in a world littered with the kind of Arctic Monkeys clones and breakbeats, something like this is refreshing beyond all shadow of a doubt. It's an awkward listen, but when given the patience it deserves, Rise Above is a beautiful album. The harmonies are perfect (and wonderfully executed live) the lyrics established already as classics and the interpretation unique. They are a wonderful, wonderful band- their talent shines on tracks like Thirsty and Miserable, Rise Above and Police story. Theirs is talent without boundaries.

Add your comment

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox:

Dirty Projectors CDs