NME Reviews

Muse

HAARP

Rejoice, for Muse have finally seen fit to release last summer’s Wembley Stadium spectaculars in full sound and vision! First, though, with bruising inevitability, here’s the science bit. No conventional ‘Live At Wembley’ titles for Muse. ‘HAARP’ is the acronym for something called the High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program, a US military-funded project in Alaska concerned with beaming high-frequency radio waves into the ionosphere. It’s supposed to be a science experiment to increase understanding of the way the atmosphere works. However, some have complained that beaming that amount of energy skywards could be used for fouler ends. There has been talk of shadowy figures using the technology to disable or destroy enemy spacecraft, to control weather patterns, block global communications, disrupt human mental processes, control minds, or provoke all-out ‘geophysical warfare’. Needless to say, Russia doesn’t approve. So here’s another handy conspiracy theory for Barmy Bellamy to tie to his music, you might think. And you might be right.

However, ponder for a moment: the power of sound. Global cataclysm brought about by massive amounts of sound – or music – falling into the wrong hands. If we’re being melodramatic about things (and with Muse, you kind of have to be) could our heroes be making a veiled reference of their own? The energy that was whipped up by those 150,000 people at Wembley had to go somewhere… Muse, it seems, were that weekend dealing in forces that were bigger than even they could comprehend. It’s always been about scale for the once Teignmouth-based trio, and for those two days at Wembley last year the stakes had never been higher. George Michael might have waded in at the last minute and stolen their exclusive at the new stadium, but this was still a band fulfilling their promise to reach for heights that most earthly bands rarely dare. It was do or be disappointed forever. So they did.

This double disc set documents the whole thing, a truncated live album of the Saturday (The Streets day) and a DVD movie of Sunday (My Chemical Romance day). Sensibly, the DVD concentrates on simply showing a great concert rather than being a great concert film. Yet it might have been nice to see a docu-form film showing the band’s adventures backstage and beyond, like Green Day’s excellent ‘Bullet In A Bible’ package of their Milton Keynes shows. Some might say that they’ve been upstaged by the U2 3D project. However, Muse were never good at small talk, and they certainly don’t need red herring gimmicks. Much better to concentrate on the drama of the performance – and what dramatic performances these were.It begins with Matt, Dom and Chris in full Christ-like symbolism mode, raised up from an underground bunker in the middle of the crowd amid a tickertape fountain seemingly aimed at the mouth of heaven itself. They launch straight into ‘Knights Of Cydonia’, a song that, throughout the whole tour, Muse have incorrectly assumed is a suitable opener, while really it is the most perfect finale (the show ends, still stunningly, with ‘Black Holes And Revelations’’ album opener ‘Take A Bow’).

It’s still a staggering spectacle. The band had wanted to fly blimps and satellites all over the shop but it was never necessary. What’s iconic is the image of these three small men absolutely owning this gigantic stadium. Wembley looks like a space telescope even without Muse’s lashings of satellite dishes and acrobats gliding across the sky suspended from giant white balloons. They do a damn fine job of convincing you they are about to fly off into the sky, and it’s this sense of sheer scale that ‘HAARP’ maybe can’t quite realise, simply because no film could. Muse have been like a spaceship circling pop consciousness for almost a decade now, but it’s still something to listen to the CD half of the HAARP package and be blown away by the range and quantity of hits they’ve racked up: the baroque melodrama of ‘Butterflies & Hurricanes’, ‘Supermassive Black Hole’’s sleek robopop, ‘Map Of The Problematique’’s Blade Runner-ish soundscapes, ‘Time Is Running Out’’s low-slung new wave, ‘New Born’’s neoclassical acrobatics and the DVD-only ‘Soldier’s Poem’’s, er, barbershop. The shows also saw rare dustings off of single ‘Unintended’, still the most heart-rending ballad moment the band have ever pulled off, and a nuke up the arse of those who would claim that Muse can’t do emotion.

But back to this global conspiracy business. Anyone who was there will testify that these shows dealt in awesome forces and this package depicts the heartstopping power of a rock show scaled up to the ultimate degree. Is the HAARP project a suitable moniker? Could Muse at Wembley generate so much high-frequency supernoise as to bring about geophysical apocalypse? Maybe not. But it was the most thrilling live moment of last year, and so it follows that this is likely to be the most essential live album we’ll see in this one.

8 out of 10

Comments (19)

Add a comment

michaelmorrisdesign 

Mar 21, 2008

an absolutly sterling album :)

HystericalGemini 

Mar 21, 2008

Stellar of an album. Best live track on the DVD? Take A Bow, an exquisit ending to a fantastic show. However, dissapointed at the lack of extras and footage of the boys. Still, a beautiful bundle of space prog-rock and blinding riffs.

wiggy2 

Mar 22, 2008

The live combined CD & Dvd package is superb value & a great reminder of how good the original concerts were back in June. Highlights on the Dvd are an 8 minute classic recording of New Born & also Knights of Cydonia. The only downside is that some of the excellent camera shots are flashed too quickly on the screen when a longer view would make better viewing. This is especially the case with Supermassive Black Hole where a longer shot would show how magnificent the robots were on the lighting set instead of mere glimpses.

DVJR0102 

Mar 22, 2008

An absolutly amazing live ablum, and I am so glad I was there... although I was at the 16th June gig, where the gig took place during the dark were the effects were soo much better, and they played Citizen Erased (one of my favs and I can't beleive it was missed out on the album). But that doesn't matter, I still enjoyed watching the other gig which was fantastic, and listening to the one I went to and I even remember Dom saying before Supermassive Black Hole "This next song is for anyone who likes a bit of R&B"... 10/10!

moosaidthedog 

Mar 23, 2008

How dare you accuse Muse of opening "incorrectly" with Knights of Cydonia. It's an incredible opener, I wouldn't have it any other way. Delightfully deranged wailing is a great way to start any occasion, let alone a Muse gig, so quit dissing

Geo91 

Mar 23, 2008

Is it just me or did it look a bit empty? I was at the gig in the 16th, and I'm dissapointed that they only put the 17th on the DVD. They didn't even put the whole gig on the DVD, missed a few highlights off (Sunburn, Citize Erased) . However, the gigs were a monumental achievement for a current ,relevant, british band. Congratulations Muse.
P.S. I agree Knights would have been the best finale...ever

j205james 

Mar 23, 2008

This was probably THE best gig i ever have, and maybe ever will go to, and it is fully captured on this 2 disc set. I went to MK with green day and that was amazing, but Muse seem to be in a league of their own!! Was a bit of a shame that Citizen Erased was dropped from the album...i wonder why? For killer riffs and a live performance to DIE for...this is the DVD to get!! 10/10...incredible.

sarahiscool 

Mar 24, 2008

i went both days and both days were amazing, but the sunday really blew me away they were alot more relaxed so i can see why the sunday made it on the dvd.
the dvd is brilliant but stupid they put in hoodoo instead of bliss. when bliss is a muse live anthem!
but still 10/10

rick 13 

Mar 24, 2008

FUCKIN SHITE!!!

wellduhobviously 

Mar 24, 2008

They closed with 'Knights...' at Lollapalooza last year and it was off the fucking chain. So much so, I then went out and bought the three albums I didn't have having decided my boycott was no longer necessary.

TheRomancehasMuseabuse 

Mar 25, 2008

absolutly aMazing!!!!
the fact they opened with 'Knights.....' && closed with 'Take A Bow' was daring but pretty clever ;)
Hope they keep it up!!

battenburgqueen 

Mar 27, 2008

Aaaah, I relived the best weekend of my life when HAARP was released. What a gig, what a band. And opening with Knights of Cydonia, which I agree is a show-stopper that would work just as well at the end of a set, was nothing short of spectacular and just what I expect from Muse: a pleasant surprise.

mozza0130 

Mar 29, 2008

leaving out bliss on the 16h gig and the DVD is a sore loss

Tyler Jensen 

Mar 30, 2008

One of the best concert experiences of all time... Attended with the best of company. Gooooood times.

NabooandhisMiracleWax 

Apr 1, 2008

This is a brilliant live album by the Muse lads, I never wanted it to end! An explosive beginning with Knights of Cydonia, great versions of Time is Running Out, Starlight, Invincible & Map of the Problematique and an electric ending of Take a Bow. Well done, lads! Even my Muse-hating dad enjoyed this!

Jo1981 

Apr 1, 2008

What a great event this was at the time, looking at the DVD now gets me as excited as I was then, shame there is no plug in baby on the CD though!

SuperBeck 

Apr 4, 2008

I went on the 17th June, and it was easily the best gig I have ever been too. I loved that they opened with Knights, and Take a Bow was a great end song. By the sound of the CD, Sunday was definately the best day. I can't believe that Plug In Baby isn't on the CD, and Bliss is on neither! 2 great tracks that they missed out on.

muserock7997 

May 7, 2008

absolutly brilliant!

James p 

May 15, 2008

i was there it was fucking quality

Add your comment

NME Alerts

Get NME news delivered direct to your desktop. Find out more

Please sign in

Forgot your password?

Register with MyNME

Every Tuesday

  • Breaking News stories
  • All you need to know about the week's NME magazine
  • Live, Album and Track reviews
  • Tip offs about the most important Gigs
  • All the latest NME.COM video exclusives

Every Friday

  • NME.COM's free mini-magazine
  • Gig listings for the weekend
  • All the most important Album and Track reviews
  • The week's biggest News stories
  • Competitions - with exclusive music prizes
  • plus loads more!

In The Magazine

This Week's Issue
  • The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • Agenda-setting news and fiery comment
  • Must-read interviews with the planet's hottest bands
  • Hundreds of UK gigs listed every week
  • Unrivalled access to the artists that matter
  • Subscribe today and get 1/3rd off NME