First For Music News

Album review: Placebo - 'Battle For The Sun'

All the appearance of a cure, all the reality of a disease

In medicine, for a placebo to work, the patient has to have absolute faith in the sugar pill they’ve been given. In this case, with a prayer on their glossed lips and nail varnished fingers crossed behind their back it’s entirely possible for the mentally or physically infirm to experience all the benefits of a great band. And it’s true that in parts ‘Battle For The Sun’, Placebo’s fifth studio album, will give the open-minded/easily-fooled aspartame butterflies in the stomach, methadone iris dilation and nicotine-patch heart tremors. By far and away the best song here, ‘Ashtray Heart’ is named after the band’s initial, 15-year-old incarnation, and has the closest to a ‘classic’ Placebo sound. Elsewhere, however, the synthetic, breezy Britpop of ‘Kings Of Medicine’ and the subpar Primal Scream-style Dixie-rock honking of ‘For What It’s Worth’ point to what this album’s really about: a desperately transparent copy of originality. For those who still believe in them, Placebo will, at least, remain an efficacious live band at festivals this summer, but only given that the real thing (Suede, Muse, David Bowie, Nirvana et al) isn’t currently on offer.

John Doran

More on this artist:
Placebo NME Artist Page
Placebo MySpace

6 out of 10
 
 
 

Comments (12)

Add a comment

legghiu 

Jun 9, 2009

man, i'm ok with suede, bowie and maybe nirvana...but did placebo have a time machine in 1996 to see the futureand copy the muse? maybe marty mc fly was playing plug in baby and jerry molko (brian's cousin) phoned them

Sadie007 

Jun 11, 2009

You know for a start this is their 6th album and I'm sure I'm not the only one to think your review is based on a total lack of insight and basically guilty of copying others 'assumed' opinion of this band and indeed this album- kind of ironic since you talk of originality.. so yeah I'm a person proud to still believe in them and no I'm not "easily fooled" - just a lover of one of he best bands this country has produced, what a shame you cant see it....

axemblack 

Jun 11, 2009

The fact that the reviewer points out Ashtray Heart as the best song on the album only goes to highlight his shallow appreciation thereof. Also, the review itself reflects a far worse score than was awarded...so which is it? God I am sick of NME reviewers who think they can infer the songwriters' intentions...?! He states in the review it's Placebo's 5th studio album, however I wonder if he's even f***ing heard them... Placebo have adapted their style on each and every album rather than subscribe to the ludditism of some of the bands that preceded them. If that's what 'a desperately transparent copy of originality' sounds like, then I just don't know what to think.

Geo91 

Jun 11, 2009

They probably didn't have a time machine, no.

IndieWriter 

Jun 11, 2009

I agree, ashtray heart is a quality song, but the rest of this album is like 40 minutes of 'mehhhhhh'

im-feelin-this 

Jun 11, 2009

Nice analogy and all. However 'Ashtray Heart' is by no means 'by far and away' the best track on the album. No doubt there are a few weak songs (For What Its Worth, Breathe Underwater..) but after a few listen throughs there are far more excellent tracks than this review suggests. (Kitty Litter, Battle For The Sun, Julien, Speak In Tongues, Happy Your Gone are all up to standards set by Sleeping with gosts and Meds- two unbelievable albums!) Not the best album Placebo have put out- but I don't think it could be expected to reach standards of the past. Still a decent album though.

Museician 

Jun 11, 2009

I like Placebo but i'm sorry to report that from wht i've listened too so far this is pretty terrible. Although all i've heard from it is a 6 song sample on Spotify, but, I will make the effort too listen to the whole thing, but i'm not getting my hopes up.

wellduhobviously 

Jun 15, 2009

Sleeping With Ghosts was the point where Placebo lost me, and it doesn't sound like Meds or this album is going to bring me back any time soon.A huge shame - the first two albums especially are still electrifying.

redup 

Jun 15, 2009

I've heard 4 first tracks from the album in music shop in Barcelona. Horrible.6/10 is too high mark for the album.Frankly speaking their first 2 albums were good but then the group totally lost the plot. I wonder that anyone is giving shit about them - especially when so much good music is around (Belle&Sebastian, Shins, Flaming Lips, Cribs).

cinemastar74 

Jun 18, 2009

i dont know if you guys are listening to the same album or not but to me it sounds like their best work....Belle and sebastian??? Flaming lips???? Give me an F-N break!!!

samspade10 

Jun 21, 2009

Newer readers or newer Placebo fans may not be aware what is going on here. NME have had a massive grudge against Placebo since one of their editors had a disagreement with them between WYIN and Black Market Music. Before that, they loved them, since then, they have set out every review to attack them and even used to use their own letters page to attack them and their fans. It was shameful abuse of journalism I have refused to but the paper edition of NME ever since. Things have mellowed since then, believe me, this review is kind by NME standards.

dantito 

Jul 22, 2009

whats the thing NME have with Placebo? I hear they hate them, why? this review show it.... lolanyways I love placebo....

Add your comment

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox:

Placebo CDs