First For Music News

Album Review: The Rumble Strips - 'Welcome To The Walk Alone'

Devon band’s quality is on the slide: blame Ronson… and their lack of ideas

Idea for a TV series: When Good Bands Go Bad. It’s got it all! Power, sex, intrigue and bright-eyed sensitive types gazing into the abyss and realising that hey, nice guys finish last. Put a moderately successful British indie band at one end of a field, a big pile of cash at the other and watch them trip over themselves to surrender their integrity on the way to get it, crying and compromising along the way. First up for Episode One are The Rumble Strips.

It turns out that branding, a rigidly defined and unique selling point and blanket advertising can’t make you anything you’re not: like any good. ‘Welcome To The Walk Alone’ may have the skeletal blueprint of pop genius running through it like words in a stick of rock but it verges on insulting. Mark Ronson production, chirpy post-pop guitars, luvvy-duvvy-wuvvy heart-on-sleeve lyrics about pwetty girls… and yes, you can guarantee there’ll be bloody trumpets. On lead single ‘Not The Only Person’ they’re obviously shooting for Orange Juice’s ‘Blue Boy’ with the euphoric melody and yelping vocals, but the textbook string section is hollow and, in its most faux-earnest moments, Charlie Waller’s voice verges on the vomit-inducing. We can’t help pining for the vibrant and enthused band that took the NME Tour by storm and wondering when making it all so slick that personality bounces straight off became so damn important.

Some people love this kind of animatronic metamorphosis, but only the kind of people who went to Glastonbury this year because Grazia rated it five phwoars out of five on the manometer. This is obviously good news for the music industry: upper-middle-class Big Brother rejects tend to have a lot of expendable income because they only buy cocaine and live with their parents. Squeezing yourself into the already-bulging mould of Razorlight, The Kooks et al is still more likely to guarantee you a low status main stage billing than actually sounding good, and so creativity takes a back seat.
Luckily, ‘Mark Ronson-produced’ has already become synonymous with ‘garish and unlistenable’, so we’re
saved the inevitable crushing disappointment when The Next Big Thing turns out to be just another
indie-by-numbers, stadium-filling, over-produced, shamelessly derivative, five-man, smug-faced shit factory. We like to imagine the recording process involved Ronson beating them with sticks and screaming, “Be more epic!” This album is the solitary cockroach scuttling around in the post-apocalyptic nuclear wasteground of British music circa-2001. Pick any song on the album you like; ‘London’ (The Young Knives did it better), any other song (The Futureheads did it better). It’s shameful. Well presented and immaculately recorded, but still shit sub-Maccabees schlock.

And the pilfering doesn’t end there: this album will be massive, but that’s no excuse for not picking apart the underlying laziness that makes its advert-friendly wipe-clean Stepford Wives-rock so hard to stomach. Opening track ‘Welcome To The Walk Alone’ sounds like The Killers after their second lobotomy while both ‘Raindrops’ and ‘Daniel’, like much of the album, cherry-pick from The Last Shadow Puppets without recognising that it’s not just a matter of gunning through it like Justin Lee Collins doing a big band sketch on The Sunday Night Project.

Then there’s the filler and, dear God, there’s a lot of filler. We barely remember what ‘Sweet Heart Hooligan’ sounds like because it keeps getting mixed up in our head with the music from the Müller Rice advert, but then you know what they say about small mercies.

Oh well, they look pretty old – this was probably their last shot at making a go of doing ‘something they love’ so maybe selling their soul to Satan was fair enough, something we like to call ‘Wombats Syndrome’. Hopefully, it’s deadly.

Rebecca Robinson

What do you think of the album? Let us know by posting a comment below.






4 out of 10
 
 
 

Comments (11)

Add a comment

Explorer45 

Jul 21, 2009

I loved the first album, and yes, I love this second album too. Anyone that says "Sweet Heart Hooligan" is forgettable, has only played it once! I was at the the album launch gig at Wilton Hall last week, and heard the live performance of every track from the new album. The performance was nothing less than sensational, and I have to strongly disagree with Rebecca, who seems to have got herself into the rut of regurgitating the usual trite comparisons with other bands. Rebecca, the "bloody trumpets" are a hallmark of the Strips and it is brass that has made them stand out against the current indie noise, now widely copied by other bands, but sadly lacking the rythymic integration that the Strips do so well. The critical zeitgeist seems to be divided into two camps, those that love or hate Ronson. For the latter group it is fashionable to pronounce that Ronson ruins good bands who sell their souls and try to piggy back on his own success. Let me assure readers that the Strips have not sold their soul to the anti-Christ, and advise them to listen to this album which contrary to the above review, is

J-e-d 

Jul 22, 2009

It's Rebecca Robinson, what do you expect? If she even catches a whiff that a song might be liked by someone who can't name everyone who's ever been in The Fall then it is immediately condemned as heartless sell out crap.

FooKnew 

Jul 22, 2009

The only thing to complete this would be a video of the reviewer licking the tears off the faces of the band, as they read her scathing words.

barryjamesmccarthy 

Jul 22, 2009

Rebecca, regarding your last comment "oh well they look pretty old" What the fuck has that got to do with anything? Thanks for telling me the albums shit, fine, thanks for your middle class opinion, it probably is shit. But "they're old? I have news for you. You will get old too, and still love music. One day we will all die, and then there is nothing. There is no God. Just death. So while we're on the planet we should be able to make music, albeit shit, without restrictions from quasi fascists like yourself. Not all of us can have rich Mummies and Daddies to start us out young. Love and peace, grow up and get a life.

lomsky 

Jul 22, 2009

Now I'm not a fan of Rumble Strips in the slightest, but this reviewer is bloody terrible. It's that same trite style you often find in student newspapers. You surely can't charge people for this kind of journalism? You could find this kind of rubbish for free on Amazon.

IndieWriter 

Jul 22, 2009

i think this review is symptomatic of the 'loving the smell of your own self-righteous, indier than thou shit' syndrome. Rather than writing to prove how cool you are, try reviewing the actual album

The man they call Raven 

Jul 23, 2009

typical NME review. We liked (insert name of band here) when they first came out - they were mediocre but they didn't make it big so they were edgy and cool. Now they're back with second album where they have sadly tried to do something that will make them successful and probably mean that more people will buy and listen to their music. Sell outs. How dare they try and make a success of their career - now what's the quickest way to bury them, as this clearly cannot be tolerated. Unless they're Razorlight and Johnny Fucking Borrell of course.

nickjcray 

Jul 27, 2009

Nowhere near as good as the last album. Shame really cos this band are a quality act. Maybe 6/10 would be fair still worth a purchase though.

1984orwell 

Jul 27, 2009

Mark Ronson is an oxygen thief!

BobbyHiggins 

Jul 29, 2009

After repeated listens I will admit I don't love it as much as the first album. Though to top that would be an almighty feat, it was almost a perfect album.This aint a Mark Ronson album, it;'s a rumble strips album and it's still better than 99% of the crap out there today, you comehow write them off against in your review. The brass section on either album are not a tribute to f**king dexy's as everyone wants to claim. They are the rumble strips in Charlie they have the best british singer out there today.

black tooth 

Aug 4, 2009

I thought the new Rumble Strips album was great actually. Mark Ronson is still a dick though.

Add your comment

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox:

The Rumble Strips CDs