The ‘Challenging’ Albums Everyone Should Own

The ideal record collection can’t be all pop-bangers and infectious indie choruses. No, at some point you have to celebrate the thorny, more avant-garde corners of the music world. Here, then, are a few ‘difficult’ albums that we love. Suggest your own by posting a comment. And no, The Enemy’s ‘Music For The People’ doesn’t count.

James McMahon
Deus, ‘In A Bar, Under The Sea’. An infuriating band at the best of times – for every soul saving alt. rock belter they’ve got three songs with bassoon solos in them. And there’s lots of songs with bassoon solos on their second record. Yet amongst the jazzy mush, the dirgy Beefheart obsessed piano ballads, the ones where Tom Barman sounds like a tramp spitting out his own teeth, there’s a song called ‘Serpentine’. It would shine like a diamond even embedded in the sun. Amongst the shit produced by the band at their most self-indulgent, it positively radiates.

Jamie Fullerton
Liars, ‘They Were Wrong, So We Drowned’. Just before they got too clattery, the perfect balance between hypnotic fuzz-grooves and mental noises like Blair Witches trapped in radiators.

David Moynihan
Aphex Twin, ‘Selected Ambient Works 85-92’. Tracks like ‘Ageopolis’, ‘Heliospan’, ‘Xtal’, ‘Tha’ and ‘Pulsewidth’ soar majestically or bubble along beautifully. At the other end of the spectrum the likes of ‘Green Calx’, ‘Hedphelym’ and ‘We Are The Music Makers’ are guaranteed to make someone near you splutter, “What the FUCK are you listening to?”

Hamish MacBain
Captain Beefheart, ‘Trout Mask Replica’. Just for the bit where he goes: “A squid eating dough in a polyethylene bag is fast and bulbous. Got me?”

Luke Lewis
Of Montreal, ‘Skeletal Lamping’. With its crazy lurches of tempo and subject matter – complete with pretentious song titles like ‘Triphallus, To Punctuate!’ – a lot of this album sounds like pop music as filtered through the mind of a swivel-eyed psycho. I initially hated. I think I still sort of hate it, but at least I can appreciate its genius.

Tim Chester
King Crimson, ‘In The Court Of The Crimson King (An Observation by King Crimson)’. The prog pioneers’ first album exploded into an unsuspecting ’69 a beautiful mess of discordant guitars, twisted brass and about 17 time signatures, and introduced the world to the unhinged genius of Robert Fripp.