Nick Cave discusses receiving criticism online: “Negativity, cynicism and resentment will not do”

"There is nothing quite like a good death threat in the morning to get the juices flowing"

Nick Cave has discussed receiving hateful messages and criticism online in a new edition of The Red Hand Files.

On his website, which sees Cave answering fan-submitted questions, a fan named Pat asked: “In this time of illness, cynicism and cruelty, do you receive many mean or vile messages? How do you cope with that kind of negative energy?”

In response, Cave wrote: “The letters sent to The Red Hand Files are mostly beautiful, full of love and a joy to read, but I do get the odd unkind message. Generally, though, I like them and find them weirdly energising. There is nothing quite like a good death threat in the morning to get the juices flowing.


“They are a form of validation, really, as no one with a public platform and an opinion is doing his or her job effectively if they are not being attacked from time to time.”

Cave then went on to say that he disagrees with the fan’s statement that we are living in “a time of cynicism and cruelty,” writing: “I think we are living through a frightening and deeply uncertain time, and though there are dementing and cynical voices out there, which are being emboldened and amplified by social media — that loony engine of outrage — they do not represent the voices of the many, or the good.

Nick Cave
Nick Cave – Credit: Getty

“My experience of actual people in this time is overwhelmingly positive — there is a great deal of love and mutual regard and community. I think most of us understand that in order to rise above this particular moment we must pull together, and act with civility, generosity and kindness. We have a monumental task ahead of us that will require vast reserves of energy — we must rehabilitate the world — and this fellow feeling and mutual respect is essential to the process.”

Cave added: “Of course, there is much in our world that is in need of change, to be set to rights, and clearly humanity is complex, conflicted and full of faults, but at this moment in time, when our very existence hangs in the balance, we need to come together not just in good faith and consolation, but also in a spirit of creativity and invention.

“Our existence depends upon offering the best of ourselves. Negativity, cynicism and resentment will not do. ‘We must love one another or die.'”


In another recent Red Hand Files entry, Nick Cave spoke of his previous heroin addiction. Praising Narcotics Anonymous in reply to a fan named Evan who is a recovering heroin addict, Cave wrote: “I think it would be fair to say if it weren’t for NA I probably wouldn’t have survived my heroin addiction.”

An extended version of Nick Cave’s recent live-streamed concert, ‘Idiot Prayer – Nick Cave Alone at Alexandra Palace’, is set to be screened globally in select cinemas on November 5, with an ‘Idiot Prayer’ live album being released on November 20.