Arctic Monkeys – the ‘Humbug’ reviews so far

1
 

Last night the Sheffield band aired a number of tracks from ‘Humbug’, kicking off with the album’s opening track ‘My Propeller’. Unusually, frontman Alex Turner ditched his guitar for ‘Potion Approaching’, trying his hand as an out-and-out frontman. Pic: Andy Willsher

2
 

Keep clicking for more photos from Arctic Monkeys’ Brixton warm-up gig – as well as all the reviews of ‘Humbug’ so far. According to the music review aggregator Metacritic, the album has scored an average mark of 8 out of 10, based on the views of 75 critics. Pic: Andy Willsher

3
 

Drowned In Sound were similarly even-handed. They also gave it 7, concluding that ‘Humbug’ is “eminently not astounding but it is inventive, and likeably so”. Pic: Andy Willsher

Advertisement

4
 

Joining in the guarded approval was The Times’ Stephen Dalton, who gave the album 3 out of 5: “‘Humbug’ is a meaty and serious work, but ultimately it feels like an inconclusive experiment.” Pic: Andy Willsher

5
 

In common with most publications, The Observer were measured in their praise for ‘Humbug’. Gareth Grundy wrote: “The problem is, for the first time, Turner’s words are more memorable than the tunes.” Pic: Andy Willsher

6
 

The Observer’s sister publication The Guardian also pointed out that Alex Turner’s lyrics are the most impressive thing about the album: “The lyrics are a dazzling display of what Turner can do,” wrote Alexis Petridis. Pic: Andy Willsher

7
 

Uncut were more positive than most, bestowing four stars, although reviewer Sam Richards admitted it wasn’t exactly heaving with tunes: “It’s hard to imagine many of these songs being bellowed back at the band from the Reading Festival compound.” Pic: Andy Willsher

Advertisement

8
 

Writing for BBC Music, Mike Diver penned one of the most positive reviews: “Put aside all thoughts of imminent backlash immediately, as ‘Humbug’ is Arctic Monkeys’ most enjoyably complete album to date.” Pic: Andy Willsher

9
 

Rolling Stone gave the album a solid four stars, revelling in Alex Turner’s growing maturity as a lyricist: “As in his side project, The Last Shadow Puppets, Turner plays with the role of a louche showbiz balladeer.” Pic: Andy Willsher

10
 

Spin magazine’s critic was less impressed. “This is oval-shaped music, circling around the tracks; it’s accomplished, but not particularly infectious,” wrote Sean Fennessey. Pic: Andy Willsher

Advertisement
Advertisement